How to Tell If a Watermelon Is Sweet

  •  
  •  
  • 53
  •  
  •  
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Have you wondered how to tell if a watermelon is sweet? Do you enjoy eating watermelon but hate it when it’s too watery? Some watermelons are full of flavor, while others taste more like water than anything else. Mark has been our watermelon “tester” for years. He’ll tell you that when you tap your knuckles on the outside of the melon you want to hear a hollow sound. If it sounds “dull” without the hollow sound, move on to another one.

I’m not sure that’s a foolproof approach, so if you’d like to make sure you’re always buying a sweet watermelon that satisfies your craving for fresh and delicious fruit, check out these helpful tips. You can use these tips to tell if a watermelon will taste sweet or not. In case you missed this post, How To Dehydrate Watermelon

How to Tell If a Watermelon Is Sweet

How to Tell If a Watermelon Is Sweet

Check the Size

Make sure you’re checking the size of the watermelon and comparing it with others, whether you’re at the grocery store or a farmer’s market. Some people assume that a giant watermelon is the absolute best, but that isn’t true.

Realistically, the giant watermelons often have a more significant water content than smaller ones, meaning those watermelons won’t taste nearly as sweet. In this case, bigger isn’t better. Instead, look for an average-sized watermelon to buy. You don’t want an oversized watermelon or too small of a watermelon. Instead, the goal is to find that perfect medium size.

How to Tell If a Watermelon Is Sweet

Check the Shape of the Watermelon

Carefully look at the shape of the watermelon. While the fruit is typically round, some are more oblong than others. If you see watermelons that are oblong or oval, don’t bother getting them because they’re likely less sweet because they contain more water.

It’s best to choose a round watermelon when you’re craving the sweetness that comes from this fresh fruit. If you spot the perfect round watermelon, it’s the one to buy!

Look for a Field Spot

Always check for a field spot on your watermelons before you buy them. Not all watermelons will have this spot, but if you can find some that do, they can provide you with more valuable information on the fruit.

Field Spots

What is the field spot?

The field spot is an area that appears on a watermelon that shows where it’s spent most of its time resting. Some watermelons won’t have this spot. On the other hand, some will have a slightly orange spot, and others will have a white field spot. Knowing the difference between the color of these spots is a must.

Read More of My Articles  Easy Homemade Egg Muffins

What does the orange spot mean?

If you find a watermelon with the orange field spot, it’s a good sign. It means the fruit is likely as sweet and flavorful as possible because it stayed on the vine a bit longer, giving it time to ripen to taste even better.

What does the white spot mean?

When you see a white spot on the watermelon, don’t bother buying it. The spot typically signifies that the watermelon spent more time on the ground and likely tastes more watery than sweet.

Be sure to look closely at any spots that you might see on the watermelon. Sometimes, the orange spot looks more yellow than orange. As long as it’s not white, you’re good to go.

White Spot

Examine the Exterior Color

While looking at a selection of watermelons, check out the exterior color of each one that catches your eye. Naturally, you’re going to need to look for darker watermelons. Sure, the bright colors might catch your attention first, but those are the watermelons that often taste more watery than sweet.

You may have heard the old saying, “The darker the berry, the sweeter the fruit.” It applies to watermelon as well. If the outside of the watermelon has a darker, duller appearance, it’s likely already ripe, sweet, and ready for you to eat.

Pay Attention to Any Shininess

Have you ever noticed that some watermelons have a shiny appearance on their skin? The shininess often makes people believe that these are the best watermelons to get, but that isn’t the case. Unfortunately, if you see many shiny watermelons when shopping for fruit, it means that these fruits aren’t fully ripe yet. 

If you buy them, they’re not going to taste as sweet as you’d like them to taste. If one store only has watermelons with shiny skin, don’t bother buying the fruit there. You can head to a different grocery store or farmer’s market to hopefully find what you really want.

Read More of My Articles  20 Uses for Coconut Oil

Gently Shake the Watermelon at the Store

It sounds silly, but shaking the watermelon at the store can help you decide if you’re going to buy it or not. Please don’t shake it too rough to cause damage to the watermelon. Instead, hold the watermelon with both hands and gently shake it from one side to the next.

In some instances, you can hear the water because the watermelon is full of it. If you can hear the extra water, you’ll already know to avoid that watermelon because it isn’t going to have that naturally sweet taste that you’re craving from the fruit.

Look for Webbing on Your Watermelon

Don’t forget to look for any signs of webbing on your watermelon. While this isn’t something you’re going to see on every single watermelon that you find, it’s a noticeable pattern worth paying attention to.

If you see slight webbing on different parts of a watermelon, the best thing to do is avoid buying it because it will have a watery, bland taste. If you see extensive webbing on the watermelon, on the other hand, it’s a good idea to buy it. Watermelon with more oversized webbing tends to have a sweeter taste.

Canning Books I recommend: USDA Canning Guide or the Ball Canning Guide

Final Word

If you love watermelon, but you’re tired of eating the watery ones that don’t taste sweet or have much flavor, use these simple tips to your advantage. You’ll need to carefully inspect your watermelon to check its size, shape, and other features it may have.

These features are important to pay attention to because they can signify whether the fruit will taste sweet or not. It can take time to look through the watermelons carefully, but it’s worth it to ensure that you get what you want. Now that you know how to tell if a watermelon is sweet, you can make sure you’re always getting the most flavorful fruit at any store.

Maybe you use other methods to find that special sweet-tasting watermelon. If so, please let me know so I can pass on your “secret” to my readers, they’ll appreciate it. May God Bless this world, Linda.

16 thoughts on “How to Tell If a Watermelon Is Sweet

  • June 29, 2021 at 7:09 am
    Permalink

    Thanks for the tips! We will definitely try these the next time we are purchasing a watermelon.

    Reply
    • June 29, 2021 at 7:10 am
      Permalink

      Hi Steff, it’s actually really fun to now look for the field spots!! Linda

      Reply
  • June 29, 2021 at 7:32 am
    Permalink

    I was raised up harvesting melons and cantaloupe with my grandparents every summer in SE Oklahoma. I’m a thumper but that more for ripeness than sweetness. I’m a big fan of yellow meats

    Reply
    • June 29, 2021 at 7:47 am
      Permalink

      Hi Matt, oh my gosh, what a great experience to harvest melons and cantaloupes with your grandparents!!!! I bet you learned a lot doing that! Linda

      Reply
      • June 29, 2021 at 8:07 am
        Permalink

        Learned to drive a F100 by dropping down to work the pedals then standing up to see going down the rows. The tractor was easier cause gas was on the steering wheel and I could reach the pedals but it was harder to turn so grandpa had to at the ends. He’d pick and I’d roll to the road. I can still shuck purple hulls and watch tv to this day. I learned the art of peddling, value and negotiations and that I don’t like it. I learned business and sometimes you gotta make folks pay. Figured I was a man once I could load a melon in the truck and lift hay bales and run a three in the tree pickup alone. I learned “till the jobs done” work ethic. I learned heat stroke. I learned I didn’t get in much trouble when I was working.
        Yeah I learned a lot and wouldn’t trade it. Heck it made the army easy when I joined.

        Reply
        • June 29, 2021 at 9:12 am
          Permalink

          Hi Matt, it’s crazy the things we learned growing up that was normal for us. I was cleaning houses to bring in extra money at the age of 10. I babysat kids for 50 cents an hour. I learned to sew when I could barely reach the sewing machine pedal. We learned to work, you a whole lot harder than me that’s for sure. I love the purple hulls story! I wouldn’t trade it either. The army was lucky to get you. Our country was blessed to have you serve! Great comment, more people should raise their kids like you! Linda

          Reply
  • June 29, 2021 at 9:29 am
    Permalink

    Linda, this is great. I just finished eating a watermelon this morning. It was so sweet. Not just the center. I learned to shell peas and snap beans at my grandparents. Also to pick them and to shuck corn. I learned to put thing up in the freezer, too. My grandmother had quit canning and got a freezer. She made the best “soup mix”. It was actually vegetable soup, but was so good. She put all kinds of fresh vegetables in it. She had a metal dish pan that she used to cook it in. She put them up in quart size bags that had the twist ties to close it up. No zipper bags back then. We’d, put an old sheet on the floor and dump the baskets full of peas or beans on it, and shell away. Those were the days. I still love to put up food.

    Reply
    • June 29, 2021 at 9:37 am
      Permalink

      Hi Deborah, oh the memories we all have! Oh my gosh, I love the soup story, the bags, and the ties! I froze soup in quart jars when my kids were growing up. I can visualize the old sheet and everyone sitting on the floor and snapping beans and shelling peas! Those were good times! Those were the days! I miss freezing corn with a neighbor years ago. As in 40+ years ago, but boy was it fun! Life is so good! Linda

      Reply
  • June 29, 2021 at 12:29 pm
    Permalink

    Perfect timing as we are in the middle of a heat wave here in the Pacific NW. Now I can look very savvy when poking through the pile of watermelons and hopefully end up with a really good one. I’ve been freezing chunks then making watermelon slushies in the blender.

    Reply
    • June 29, 2021 at 2:37 pm
      Permalink

      Hi Alice, oh my gosh, that’s a great idea!!! I’m dehydrating some chunks right now for snacks. I love slushies!! Linda

      Reply
  • June 30, 2021 at 11:05 am
    Permalink

    Linda, great tips on finding a ripe watermelon, but I’d add looking for a withered stem. A withered stem means the melon was on the vine long enough to get ripe. Also, some melon varieties, like Charleston Gray or Desert King (a delicious yellow-fleshed watermelon) are oblong by their very nature, so don’t avoid them just for their shape. In addition, while well developed webbing is a good indicator, not all melon varieties have webbing.

    Like Matt, I’m a thumper, but I don’t bother thumping any melons where I can’t see a good orange field spot and a dried up stem.

    Also like Matt, I learned to drive a tractor and a 1950 Ford pickup in my grandfather’s fields. I was seven years old and grandpa would put the pickup in low gear and I’d steer it beside the combine while he was cutting wheat in SE KS. I learned to drive the tractor when we bailed hay for the cattle, and I couldn’t turn it around at the end of the rows without his help either.

    He also had a plot devoted to watermelons. The little town of Thayer, KS, dubbed itself the watermelon capital of the world back in the 50’s.

    Oh, I am so going to use this article in my July newsletter.

    Reply
    • June 30, 2021 at 1:40 pm
      Permalink

      Hi Ray, you are so awesome! I did not see any watermelons with a stem. I will look for that next time, my friend! I’m dehydrating some right now. I think my first car was a 1951 Chevy sedan, I paid $150.00 for it. My friends helped pay for the gas to drive it to school. You drove a 1950 Ford pickup, wow, the great memories. Linda

      Reply
      • June 30, 2021 at 3:41 pm
        Permalink

        The stems I’m referring to are usually no more than 1/2″ long. Just look at both ends of the melon and if you see anything that looks brown and dried up that’s likely the stem end. If you see a “stem” that’s isn’t dried up, stay away from that one as it wasn’t allowed to ripen before being picked.

        Reply
        • June 30, 2021 at 5:50 pm
          Permalink

          Hi Ray, thanks for the tip. I did not see any stems, but I will look for them going forward! Linda

          Reply
  • July 8, 2021 at 7:48 am
    Permalink

    An elderly gentleman in the grocery store once told me to look for a very small stem spot — where the stem broke off from the watermelon. I’m assuming because the watermelon was attached longer. It’s pretty reliable. We’ve been getting a lot of spongy watermelons, which go right in the creek for the wildlife. They are disgusting. Any tests for that?

    Reply
    • July 8, 2021 at 8:54 am
      Permalink

      Hi Barbara, I have heard that about the stem as well. What a shame to have to throw it out. Linda

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *