The Best Egg Salad Sandwich Recipe Ever

  • 7
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

We all want the best egg salad sandwich recipe, right? This is the recipe I have made for years. Nothing fancy or hard to do.  Here is the link for the pressure cooker (how I hard boiled the eggs): Pressure Cooked Hard Boiled Eggs. This picture has my Whole Wheat Bread Recipe as well.

This is actually my salsa maker/chopper. This is my “secret” to my egg salad sandwich recipe. All my daughters have one of these because we like the hard boiled egg chopped really fine. I mean really fine…..this is also a salsa maker.

Finely chopped eggs

I think after this weekend we will all have so many hard boiled eggs after Easter….here is one way to use them up!

Best Egg Salad Sandwich Recipe

  • 8-9 hard-boiled eggs, peeled
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • ¾ cup Mayonnaise or Miracle Whip
  • Salt & Pepper to taste
  1. Chop the eggs as finely as possible. I use a chopper. Combine the eggs, mayonnaise or Miracle Whip. Stir in the salt, pepper, and sugar. Serve on lettuce bed or make a sandwich with the mixture.

PRINTABLE recipe:  Recipe by Food Storage Moms

Salsa maker chopper

Here are some ways you can serve with this recipe:

  1. pickles, sweet, dill, or bread and butter
  2. lettuce
  3. avocado
  4. bell peppers
  5. thinly sliced sweet onions
  6. lettuce, tomato, cucumber, green onion salad
  7. sliced cucumbers with grape tomatoes, drizzled with balsamic vinegar
  8. white bread
  9. French bread
  10. whole wheat bread
  11. croissants
  12. English muffins: mix the egg salad with a jar of pimento cheese and broil until lightly browned
  13. dinner rolls by Linda
  14. sliced tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh Mozzarella cheese, drizzled with balsamic vinegar
  15. homemade vegetable soup
  16. homemade minestrone soup
  17. tomato soup
  18. cheesy broccoli soup
  19. fruit salad
  20. fruit smoothies
  21. fruit slushies
  22. lemon water
Read More of My Articles  How To Make The Very Best Cherry Flan Cake In The World

I hope my recipe brings you joy to make some egg salad sandwiches, my family loves this simple, easy and frugal recipe. Let me know what you put in your egg salad sandwiches. Enjoy!


This post may contain affiliate links, including Using links to these sites means I may earn a small percentage of the purchase at no extra cost to you.

Follow Me In Social Media:


  1. Huh, sugar…I’ll try it. Our family recipe includes mayo, s&p and yellow mustard.

  2. Glenda Horn says:

    My recipe is way more complicated and quite delicious, despite the extras. It has celery seed, worchestershire, onions, mustard (yellow or ground), celery, parsley, lemon juice and a dash of tabasco. GOTTA HAVE celery! At my American Legion Bingo nights, people paid money for it. I kind of change it up, though, according to how I feel that day. I for sure am going to try it your way—-so cinch-y!! and I love the chopper idea. I send my eggs thru ther eggslicer in both directions.

    • Hi Glenda, I love this egg salad recipe extra ingredients! I think its awesome people would pay money for your egg salad. I think people LOVE homemade recipes and food items. I have got to try your ingredients! I LOVE new ideas, thank you so much! Linda

Share Your Thoughts